I've tried a million and a half products. I do NOT have acne, but my skin does get shiny fairly fast and I am trying to get rid of the oil...but without over-drying it. I cannot stand foundation; powder gets rid of the shine temporarily but it comes back (and worse) within a couple hours. Oil blotting sheets don't do enough. I've resigned myself to the fact that it is what I wash, tone, and moisturize with that can truly make the difference.
So far my favorite products come from Origins (Mint Wash, Oil Refiner Toner, Matte Scientist Lotion) but if anyone can beat that, I'm down to try it out.